Why is the truth so hard. Why is it necessary nowadays to vilify the other person in a dispute?
A Colorado Hospital is being purchased by a Catholic group. And already some of the doctors and the press are making it seem like health care will suffer. Of course there is a sob story about a woman who will be denied a life-saving operation because of repressive catholic morals (In fact, Catholic hospital directives would not prevent her surgery at all). And the scare tactic that people will be kept alive against their will as vegetables (this is also untrue).
Here is a letter I wrote to the paper on this article:
This article is full of misinformation about the Catholic Church and is poor journalism.
First of all, nothing in Catholic medical directives would forbid the Doctor from performing a tubal ligation on Ms. Strong. She has a legitimate medical need for it. I don't know if it is an attempt either by the hospital or the reporter to make the Catholic Church look evil but it is not true. I have been around Catholic hospitals my whole life and have seen this procedure performed many times in them.
Also, Dr. Murphey is mistaken, living wills are allowed and are followed at Catholic Hospitals.